This liquid doesn't work half as well as the original Camomile Waterproof Eye Make-up Remover (lotion version). I have been using The Body Shop's products for years for skin and hair care. After The Body Shop discontinued the lotion version of the Camomile Makeup remover and replaced it with the liquid and cream, I have been searching for something else that works as well and is gentle on my skin. Please hear my plea: Please Bring Back the Lotion Version! It seems that I am not alone in wanting this product back. I have attached a picture of the original product that I still have. Please bring it back. What you replaced it with is inferior. The liquid is drying for sensitive skin and the cream/butter does not smoothly glide over your skin like the lotion does. Someone at product development has to know you need a happy medium in between liquid and cream/butter.